Having a wonderful crime, wish you were here!

Welcome to The Mystery Game

What is The Mystery Game?

Audience Interactive Theater

So many ways to have fun!!


Murder Mystery Dinner Theater

Solve the crime.  The murder might take place during the event or may happen offsite.  Either way it's up to you to help the detective figure out who did it.  Another choice is to be part of the jury that hears the case and determines guild or innocence.


Comedy Weddngs

Be part of a hilarious wedding complete with ceremony, reception, games, dancing, cake, etc.  Ethnic themed events allow your entire party to become fully involved.


No upcoming events.


Contact Us

Drop us a line!

Better yet, see us in person!

We love our audience, so come see one of our shows.

The Mystery Game

127 Willow Pond Way, Penfield, NY 14526, us

(585) 377-9223

The Mystery Game was founded by Bruce Whitehill


"My wife laughed so hard, ..... "

The Mystery Game has provided live interactive entertainment at Deer Run Winery for over five years and our customers love attending these dinners!  The Murder Mystery Dinner Theater events are always a sell out and we have increased the number of Murder Mystery Dinners each year to try and accommodate the growing number of requests we receive from our customers.  At the end of every event, we hear the same comments from the crowd:  “It was a great night!”  “Thank you so much for holding this type of event, my wife laughed so hard, she peed her pants!”  The Mystery Game provides an evening of interactive fun and enjoyment for all in attendance! 

--Marie Kuyon, Event Coordinator

 Deer Run Winery